Initiative details
The study addresses the growing road safety concerns linked to the increasing number of electric and hybrid vehicles on Belgian roads. These vehicles are considerably quieter than conventional vehicles at low speeds, which means that pedestrians and cyclists may not hear them approaching in time. This creates a particular risk for blind and visually impaired people, who rely heavily on sound to navigate traffic environments and make safe crossing decisions. The research therefore investigated whether quiet vehicles can be detected early enough to guarantee safety and whether current countermeasures are sufficiently effective.
Initiative date
to
Who was/is your target audience?
Policy makers
Public authorities
Topic
Create awareness
Knowledge building and sharing
Organisation details
Vias institute
School / Research centre
Belgium
Brussels
Contact name
Sophie Vanhove
Telephone number
+32496103987
sophie.vanhove@vias.be
Website link
Project activities
If you work together with external partners, list the most important partners and briefly describe their role.
We worked together with various associations for blind and visually impaired people, such as Symfoon and Markgrave.
Please describe the project activities you carried/are carrying out and the time period over which these were implemented.
The project combined several complementary research activities to gain a complete understanding of the issue.
First, the researchers conducted a literature review to examine existing scientific evidence on the detectability of quiet vehicles, the importance of sound for pedestrian safety, and the effectiveness of solutions such as the Acoustic Vehicle Alerting System (AVAS).
Second, they carried out 15 semi-structured interviews with blind and visually impaired people. These interviews explored how participants travel independently, how they use sound to orient themselves in traffic, and how the growing presence of electric vehicles affects their feeling of safety.
Third, the researchers performed objective sound measurements on five vehicles, including electric, hybrid and conventional vehicles. They recorded sounds during different manoeuvres such as driving at a constant speed, accelerating, decelerating and reversing, and analysed both the sound level and frequency spectrum.
And finally, they conducted a detectability experiment with 70 participants, half of whom were blind or visually impaired. Participants listened to vehicle recordings under different speeds and background noise conditions and indicated when they detected an approaching vehicle. This allowed the researchers to compare the detectability of different vehicle types in realistic traffic situations.
First, the researchers conducted a literature review to examine existing scientific evidence on the detectability of quiet vehicles, the importance of sound for pedestrian safety, and the effectiveness of solutions such as the Acoustic Vehicle Alerting System (AVAS).
Second, they carried out 15 semi-structured interviews with blind and visually impaired people. These interviews explored how participants travel independently, how they use sound to orient themselves in traffic, and how the growing presence of electric vehicles affects their feeling of safety.
Third, the researchers performed objective sound measurements on five vehicles, including electric, hybrid and conventional vehicles. They recorded sounds during different manoeuvres such as driving at a constant speed, accelerating, decelerating and reversing, and analysed both the sound level and frequency spectrum.
And finally, they conducted a detectability experiment with 70 participants, half of whom were blind or visually impaired. Participants listened to vehicle recordings under different speeds and background noise conditions and indicated when they detected an approaching vehicle. This allowed the researchers to compare the detectability of different vehicle types in realistic traffic situations.
In terms of implementation, what worked well and what challenges did you need to overcome?
One of the main strengths of the project was the successful collaboration with organisations representing blind and visually impaired people. Through partnerships with these associations, the research team was able to recruit participants efficiently and reach the target group most affected by the issue of quiet vehicles. The response was extremely positive: many people were eager to participate and expressed a strong interest in the topic. In fact, the number of volunteers exceeded the available places in the study, meaning that some interested participants had to be turned away. This high level of engagement underlined both the relevance of the research and the importance that blind and visually impaired people attach to improving road safety in this area.
Another key success factor was the multidisciplinary approach. By combining interviews, objective sound measurements and a detectability experiment, the study generated both technical and user-centred insights. Although the experimental methods were new to the research team, extensive preparation, a thorough review of the scientific literature and the support of experts helped to refine the methodology and ensure that the measurements and experiments were as realistic and reliable as possible. As a result, the study was able to produce evidence-based findings and concrete recommendations for policymakers and vehicle manufacturers.
Another key success factor was the multidisciplinary approach. By combining interviews, objective sound measurements and a detectability experiment, the study generated both technical and user-centred insights. Although the experimental methods were new to the research team, extensive preparation, a thorough review of the scientific literature and the support of experts helped to refine the methodology and ensure that the measurements and experiments were as realistic and reliable as possible. As a result, the study was able to produce evidence-based findings and concrete recommendations for policymakers and vehicle manufacturers.
Evaluation
Please summarise how you have evaluated the initiative’s impact (e.g. social media reach, survey, feedback forms, statistics).
The research was evaluated through a combination of qualitative and quantitative methods.
The qualitative evaluation consisted of interviews with visually impaired participants. These interviews provided insights into how people use auditory information in everyday traffic situations, the challenges they face, and their perceptions of quiet vehicles and AVAS systems.
The quantitative evaluation had two components. First, researchers measured and analysed the actual sound emissions of different vehicle types. Second, they tested vehicle detectability through a controlled listening experiment. Participants were exposed to recordings of electric, hybrid and combustion-engine vehicles travelling at speeds of 10, 20, 30 and 50 km/h and under different levels of ambient noise. Researchers then compared detection distances, missed detections and perceived safety across participant groups and vehicle types.
This mixed-method approach ensured that the findings reflected both objective measurements and the real-life experiences of vulnerable road users.
The qualitative evaluation consisted of interviews with visually impaired participants. These interviews provided insights into how people use auditory information in everyday traffic situations, the challenges they face, and their perceptions of quiet vehicles and AVAS systems.
The quantitative evaluation had two components. First, researchers measured and analysed the actual sound emissions of different vehicle types. Second, they tested vehicle detectability through a controlled listening experiment. Participants were exposed to recordings of electric, hybrid and combustion-engine vehicles travelling at speeds of 10, 20, 30 and 50 km/h and under different levels of ambient noise. Researchers then compared detection distances, missed detections and perceived safety across participant groups and vehicle types.
This mixed-method approach ensured that the findings reflected both objective measurements and the real-life experiences of vulnerable road users.
What has been the effect of the activities?
The study confirmed that sound plays a crucial role in road safety, especially for people with visual impairments. The interview participants explained that they continuously use sounds from traffic and their surroundings to build a mental picture of the environment and identify potential hazards. Quiet vehicles therefore create uncertainty because they can be more difficult to detect. The sound measurements showed that electric vehicles produce less noise, particularly in higher frequencies and at lower speeds. However, the AVAS system can significantly improve detectability and, depending on the design of the sound, can make electric vehicles almost as audible as conventional vehicles. The detectability experiment found that an electric vehicle equipped with AVAS could generally be detected as well as a vehicle with an internal combustion engine. The hybrid vehicle tested was somewhat less detectable, especially in environments with high background noise.
A key finding was that many vehicles, regardless of propulsion type, were often detected too late or not detected at all in noisy urban environments. This suggests that ambient traffic noise itself is a major road safety concern. The study also found that participants could not always correctly judge whether they had enough time to cross safely after detecting a vehicle, which may lead to risky decisions.
A key finding was that many vehicles, regardless of propulsion type, were often detected too late or not detected at all in noisy urban environments. This suggests that ambient traffic noise itself is a major road safety concern. The study also found that participants could not always correctly judge whether they had enough time to cross safely after detecting a vehicle, which may lead to risky decisions.
Please briefly explain why your initiative is a good example of improving road safety.
This study is a strong example of road safety improvement because it addresses an emerging safety challenge created by the transition towards more sustainable mobility. While electric vehicles provide environmental benefits, the research highlights potential unintended consequences for vulnerable road users and identifies ways to reduce those risks.
The project is particularly valuable because it combines scientific evidence, technical measurements and the lived experiences of blind and visually impaired people. This ensures that the conclusions are both evidence-based and grounded in real-world mobility needs.
In addition, the research does not merely identify a problem. It evaluates an existing solution, the AVAS system, and provides practical recommendations for policymakers and manufacturers, such as standardising AVAS sounds, improving sound design, raising awareness among electric vehicle drivers and exploring complementary technologies. These recommendations can help make roads safer while supporting the continued adoption of electric vehicles.
Overall, the study demonstrates how proactive research can identify new risks, assess effective countermeasures and support evidence-based road safety policy before a problem becomes more widespread.
The project is particularly valuable because it combines scientific evidence, technical measurements and the lived experiences of blind and visually impaired people. This ensures that the conclusions are both evidence-based and grounded in real-world mobility needs.
In addition, the research does not merely identify a problem. It evaluates an existing solution, the AVAS system, and provides practical recommendations for policymakers and manufacturers, such as standardising AVAS sounds, improving sound design, raising awareness among electric vehicle drivers and exploring complementary technologies. These recommendations can help make roads safer while supporting the continued adoption of electric vehicles.
Overall, the study demonstrates how proactive research can identify new risks, assess effective countermeasures and support evidence-based road safety policy before a problem becomes more widespread.
How have you shared information about your project and its results?
We have shared the report via newspaper, radio, social media and our newsletter.
Supporting materials